Skip to main content
Summary
Vinyl & Bug Doors
Advantages
- Low maintenance
- Few moving parts
- Easy to repair
- Break-away bottom bar
- Higher cycle-life
- Safer around pedestrians
Disadvantages
- Not good for security
- Not suited for higher winds
- No insulation value
Roll-up Metal Doors
Advantages
- Good for security
- Higher winds
- Made to cover large areas
- Replaceable door slates
Disadvantages
- Not suited for high use
- Repair cost are higher
- Roll tube is larger
- Easy to damage with motorized equipment
- More dangerous around pedestrians
Roll-up Counter Doors
Advantages
- Good for security
- Higher winds
- Made to cover large areas
- Replaceable door slates
- Has a smaller rollbox
Disadvantages
- Not suited for high use
- Higher Initial cost than conventional metal doors
Loading Dock Doors
Advantages
- Good for security
- Higher winds
- Break-away panels
- Replaceable door slates
- Insulated
Disadvantages
- Higher Initial cost than conventional metal roll-up doors
Shutter Doors
Advantages
- Good for security
- higher winds
- covering larger areas
- Has a smaller rollbox
Disadvantages
- Not suited for high use
- Higher Initial cost than conventional mental doors
Door Comparison Chart
Security Shutters vs. Vinyl Roll-Up Doors
| Feature | Security Shutters | Vinyl and Bug Roll-Up Doors |
|---|---|---|
| Main use | Security for storefronts, service counters and windows | Busy industrial doorways, pest and temperature control |
| Curtain | Rigid aluminum slats | Flexible 23 oz. or 40 oz. vinyl, or bird, bug or gnat mesh |
| Impacts | Resists forced entry | Break-away bottom bar tabs let the curtain pop out when a forklift hits it |
| Speed | About 6 in. per second | 12 to 30 in. per second (50 to 100 on high speed doors) |
| Use per day | Light use, 1 to 6 cycles an hour | Up to 100 cycles a day on high-cycle doors |
| Insulation | Foam-filled privacy slats cut heat and noise | None; fine on coolers, never on freezers |
| Around people | Made for storefronts and counters, not traffic lanes | Soft curtain is safer around people and forklifts |
| Mounting | Wall or in-jamb | Wall, in-jamb, stand-off or E-track |
